1  Colombia

1.1 Project-856

This project is the only one for which reproducible code was provided. We therefore assume that the selected donors match those used in the publication. The number of donors and the size of the donor pool match exactly what is reported in Table A9 of the supplementary materials. However, the locations appear not to match those in Fig. S4..

Figure 1.1: Colombia-Project-856 synthetic control; comprising 6 donors from a potential pool of 62 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.2

Figure 1.2: Colombia-Project-856 synthetic control map

1.2 Project-1390

This SC matches that of the paper.

Figure 1.3: Colombia-Project-1390 synthetic control; comprising 4 donors from a potential pool of 109 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.2

Figure 1.4: Colombia-Project-1390 synthetic control map

1.3 Project-1391

Figure 1.5: Colombia-Project-1391 synthetic control; comprising 4 donors from a potential pool of 87 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.3

Figure 1.6: Colombia-Project-1391 synthetic control map

1.4 Project-1392

Figure 1.7: Colombia-Project-1392 synthetic control; comprising 5 donors from a potential pool of 38 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.2

Figure 1.8: Colombia-Project-1392 synthetic control map

1.5 Project-1395

Figure 1.9: Colombia-Project-1395 synthetic control; comprising 5 donors from a potential pool of 44 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.1

Figure 1.10: Colombia-Project-1395 synthetic control map

1.6 Project-1396

Figure 1.11: Colombia-Project-1396 synthetic control; comprising 8 donors from a potential pool of 100 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.2

Figure 1.12: Colombia-Project-1396 synthetic control map

1.7 Project-1400

Figure 1.13: Colombia-Project-1400 synthetic control; comprising 3 donors from a potential pool of 48 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.1

Figure 1.14: Colombia-Project-1400 synthetic control map

1.8 Project-1566

Figure 1.15: Colombia-Project-1566 synthetic control; comprising 8 donors from a potential pool of 147 donors. The donor pool subset is based on a buffer deforestation threshold value of 0.3

Figure 1.16: Colombia-Project-1566 synthetic control map